Ally Kelley
Address
12420 Overseas Hwy,
Marathon, FL 33050
Your Middle and Lower Keys Advisor
Recognized among the top 1.5% of real estate professionals in America by RealTrends Verified and voted as Marathon’s “Best Realtor”, Ally Kelley has consistently ranked among the Florida Keys' top-producing agents. Her market insight, strategic pricing expertise, skilled negotiation, and commitment to client advocacy have contributed to numerous notable and record-setting sales throughout the region.
Ally is a top-producing real estate advisor with Ocean Sotheby's International Realty, serving buyers and sellers throughout the Middle and Lower Florida Keys. Since relocating to the Keys in 2016, she has built a reputation for delivering exceptional results, personalized service, and an elevated client experience, successfully closing more than $150 million in real estate transactions.
A fifth-generation Floridian, Ally combines deep local market knowledge with a genuine passion for the island lifestyle she calls home. Her expertise spans waterfront estates, luxury vacation homes, investment properties, and primary residences, allowing her to guide clients through every stage of the buying and selling process with confidence and clarity.
What truly distinguishes Ally is her belief that luxury is defined by the experience, not simply the price point. Every client receives the same level of care, communication, and attention to detail, whether purchasing a first home, selling a family property, or acquiring a waterfront estate. Supported by a carefully curated network of trusted local professionals, Ally provides a seamless, concierge-style approach designed to simplify the process and exceed expectations.
I met Ally through a friend in Jupiter, we connected instantly in regards to a second home in Marathon. She’s extremely knowledgeable about the different areas in town and really listened to what we wanted for our family. Ally placed us in what so happened to be a perfect condo building. Everyone is now family to us. Ally went above and beyond to make the deal happen, certain circumstances arose with the seller and Ally tended to each and every issue without question. We will definitely be using her again in the future and recommend her to anyone who is looking for an agent in the Keys.
I met Ally through a friend in Jupiter, we connected instantly in regards to a second home in Marathon. She’s extremely knowledgeable about the different areas in town and really listened to what we wanted for our family. Ally placed us in what so happened to be a perfect condo building. Everyone is now family to us. Ally went above and beyond to make the deal happen, certain circumstances arose with the seller and Ally tended to each and every issue without question. We will definitely be using her again in the future and recommend her to anyone who is looking for an agent in the Keys.
Ally was amazing! She was patient, kind, professional, and extremely knowledgeable. Her knowledge about the market, the area, and her connections to other businesses in the Keys was the only reason our deal was able to go through. I would recommend Ally to anyone and everyone.
Ally was amazing! She was patient, kind, professional, and extremely knowledgeable. Her knowledge about the market, the area, and her connections to other businesses in the Keys was the only reason our deal was able to go through. I would recommend Ally to anyone and everyone.
Ally was very responsive to our needs from the start. She understood what we were looking for but most importantly the property types we were not interested in and streamlined our searches to pinpoint viable options. Since we live out of state, she offered sound advice from a local's perspective which was helpful to narrow down our options. Ally was very accessible, patient, easy to work with, and willing to spend extra time on the phone when needed. Finding our home in such a competitive market was a challenge, but Ally made it a good experience overall. Her help with the entire process was invaluable from start to closing and beyond. It was a real pleasure working with her and we highly recommend her.
Ally was very responsive to our needs from the start. She understood what we were looking for but most importantly the property types we were not interested in and streamlined our searches to pinpoint viable options. Since we live out of state, she offered sound advice from a local's perspective which was helpful to narrow down our options. Ally was very accessible, patient, easy to work with, and willing to spend extra time on the phone when needed. Finding our home in such a competitive market was a challenge, but Ally made it a good experience overall. Her help with the entire process was invaluable from start to closing and beyond. It was a real pleasure working with her and we highly recommend her.
Honestly, I was impressed throughout my home purchase. The support I received with a difficult mortgage was fabulous. Ally had the knowledge and professionalism needed to assist me in making decisions and helped me get through some very difficult times. I always felt that she was there for me and guided me from the first day through my closing date. Ally had a smile on her face with every encounter and I always felt that I was important. I will and have recommended Ally and feel that she did an excellent job for me. As a REALTOR, she is reliable, trustworthy, honest, and very personable. I am grateful to have had Ally working for me to create my success story.
Honestly, I was impressed throughout my home purchase. The support I received with a difficult mortgage was fabulous. Ally had the knowledge and professionalism needed to assist me in making decisions and helped me get through some very difficult times. I always felt that she was there for me and guided me from the first day through my closing date. Ally had a smile on her face with every encounter and I always felt that I was important. I will and have recommended Ally and feel that she did an excellent job for me. As a REALTOR, she is reliable, trustworthy, honest, and very personable. I am grateful to have had Ally working for me to create my success story.
We decided to move to The Keys from the North East. Ally was there to help us every step of the way. It took us 6 months to decide and ally was more than happy to help the entire time. She has tons of local knowledge and local people in every field to help along the way with whatever issues arise. You can trust her from the other side of the country. She is very easy to get ahold of with whatever comes your way. I recommend Ally.
We decided to move to The Keys from the North East. Ally was there to help us every step of the way. It took us 6 months to decide and ally was more than happy to help the entire time. She has tons of local knowledge and local people in every field to help along the way with whatever issues arise. You can trust her from the other side of the country. She is very easy to get ahold of with whatever comes your way. I recommend Ally.
We worked with Ally on the purchase of our first home. She was extremely persistent in finding us the perfect home, guided us through the entire process, and answered any of our questions (and there were a lot) promptly, day, night, and weekends. She made this entire process very enjoyable and exciting. We will use Ally again for any future real estate needs and will highly recommend her any chance we get. This girl is the best!
We worked with Ally on the purchase of our first home. She was extremely persistent in finding us the perfect home, guided us through the entire process, and answered any of our questions (and there were a lot) promptly, day, night, and weekends. She made this entire process very enjoyable and exciting. We will use Ally again for any future real estate needs and will highly recommend her any chance we get. This girl is the best!
I came to Ally with no familiarity with the lower keys area, knowing that I was focused on investment there. Ally's quick response, keen intellect in the area, and competitive intel helped me succeed. She immediately recognized what I was looking for and helped me to nail down one property quickly and efficiently. I highly recommend Ally for any real estate project you seek.
I came to Ally with no familiarity with the lower keys area, knowing that I was focused on investment there. Ally's quick response, keen intellect in the area, and competitive intel helped me succeed. She immediately recognized what I was looking for and helped me to nail down one property quickly and efficiently. I highly recommend Ally for any real estate project you seek.
Ally was wonderful in helping assist us to sell our home! She paid attention to every detail and made sure the process went smoothly! Highly recommend Ally if you are looking for a truly professional REALTOR.
Ally was wonderful in helping assist us to sell our home! She paid attention to every detail and made sure the process went smoothly! Highly recommend Ally if you are looking for a truly professional REALTOR.
We highly recommend Ally Kelley. She knows the market and got us multiple offers the first weekend. Great communication from the moment we first talked to her about listing our property to closing.
We highly recommend Ally Kelley. She knows the market and got us multiple offers the first weekend. Great communication from the moment we first talked to her about listing our property to closing.
Ally is hands down the best Realtor in the Keys. She assisted us with buying our first home working with a VA loan and Hometown Heroes. She showed us exactly what we wanted to see and didn't try to show us things that we weren't looking for. She knew more about the houses we were looking at than the Realtors that were selling them. Her and the team she had working with her made this the easiest process it could possibly be. Ally knows the questions to ask, what to look for with permits and knows every one in the Keys to make the home buying process easier. I wouldn't recommend anyone but her if you're looking to buy or sell a house. Buying a home in the Keys isn't as straight forward as it is on the "main land". Ally has the tools and knowledge to exceed all of your expectations of buying a home here and get you exactly what you want!
Ally is hands down the best Realtor in the Keys. She assisted us with buying our first home working with a VA loan and Hometown Heroes. She showed us exactly what we wanted to see and didn't try to show us things that we weren't looking for. She knew more about the houses we were looking at than the Realtors that were selling them. Her and the team she had working with her made this the easiest process it could possibly be. Ally knows the questions to ask, what to look for with permits and knows every one in the Keys to make the home buying process easier. I wouldn't recommend anyone but her if you're looking to buy or sell a house. Buying a home in the Keys isn't as straight forward as it is on the "main land". Ally has the tools and knowledge to exceed all of your expectations of buying a home here and get you exactly what you want!
Ally has been helpful, thorough, and professional. It was a pleasure to work with her in selling our home. She is easy to communicate with and is prompt in finding answering and following through on all requirements and paperwork. Ally is a joy to work with. She communicates effectively, stays on top of all the parts and pieces that need to be completed to buy and sell, is easy to work with and all around makes the process as easy as possible for her clients. I highly recommend using Ally when in the market to buy or sell.
Ally has been helpful, thorough, and professional. It was a pleasure to work with her in selling our home. She is easy to communicate with and is prompt in finding answering and following through on all requirements and paperwork. Ally is a joy to work with. She communicates effectively, stays on top of all the parts and pieces that need to be completed to buy and sell, is easy to work with and all around makes the process as easy as possible for her clients. I highly recommend using Ally when in the market to buy or sell.
Our experience working with Ally was truly pleasurable. She discussed the pricing of our home and took our feelings into account during the listing process. After we listed it she kept us informed and up to date on the locations of the multiple areas of advertising for our property. She followed up regularly keeping us aware of other similar properties coming on the market as well as those recently sold, and how they might impact the pricing and sale of our home. Once the offer was received, she continued working on the details making sure nothing was forgotten or dropped. I can easily say she is one of the best agents my wife and I have ever worked with.
Our experience working with Ally was truly pleasurable. She discussed the pricing of our home and took our feelings into account during the listing process. After we listed it she kept us informed and up to date on the locations of the multiple areas of advertising for our property. She followed up regularly keeping us aware of other similar properties coming on the market as well as those recently sold, and how they might impact the pricing and sale of our home. Once the offer was received, she continued working on the details making sure nothing was forgotten or dropped. I can easily say she is one of the best agents my wife and I have ever worked with.
I've purchased a few multimillion-dollar homes in The Keys and Ally is the only REALTOR I will use. She does exactly what I ask and is polished and motivated. She followed up with me on all my calls or emails.
I've purchased a few multimillion-dollar homes in The Keys and Ally is the only REALTOR I will use. She does exactly what I ask and is polished and motivated. She followed up with me on all my calls or emails.
For Sale
$4,650,000
3742 Seagrape Street, Big Pine Key, FL 33043
Active Under Contract
$4,400,000
111 Windy Point Circle & Lot 78, Marathon, FL 33050
Active Under Contract
$4,400,000
115 Windy Point Circle, Marathon, FL 33050
For Sale
$3,495,000
58652 Overseas Highway, Marathon, FL 33050
For Sale
$1,395,000
1261 Avenue A, Big Pine Key, FL 33043
For Sale
$1,185,000
391 10th Street, Key Colony, FL 33051
Active Under Contract
$894,000
437 Pirates Road, Little Torch Key, FL 33042
For Sale
$499,000
1115 Sombrero Boulevard 102B, Marathon, FL 33050
Ally Kelley
Global Real Estate Advisor
About Me
We need more information to provide an accurate estimate for this address. Local expert Ally Kelley will reach out shortly or you can schedule a consultation now.
Property Address
Address
Luxury Presence Home Value is the current estimated value of this home. It is calculated from a comprehensive database which encompasses properties from all 50 states, covering 99% of the US population, and valuation software developed by Automated Valuation Model (AVM) Analytics.
A village stretched across a beautiful chain of Upper Keys communities.
Read MoreLong and narrow, with the Atlantic on one side and Florida Bay on the other, so water views and sea breezes are never far away.
Read MoreOne of the Middle Keys' most recognizable residential islands, known for clear canals, ornate arched bridges and a private, polished atmosphere.
Read MoreEqually suited to full-time living, a second home or a boating-centered investment, with quick access to both the Atlantic and Gulf.
Read MoreA small, incorporated island city just off Marathon, connected to the Overseas Highway by a short causeway.
Read MoreThe community offers everyday conveniences while retaining a rural, low-key personality, with wooded lots, canal-front homes and quiet residential pockets.
Read MoreA peaceful, residential setting surrounded by some of the Lower Keys' most beautiful shallow water.
Read MoreA peaceful residential living with some of the Lower Keys' most intriguing waterfront real estate.
Read MoreSugarloaf Key offers a rare combination of Lower Keys tranquility and convenient proximity to Key West.
Read MoreIsland blends historic Conch homes, grand tropical estates, lively waterfronts, galleries, restaurants and a deeply rooted creative culture.
Read MoreAugust 27, 2026
August 20, 2026
August 13, 2026
August 6, 2026
August 6, 2026
July 23, 2026
July 16, 2026
July 9, 2026
July 2, 2026
June 25, 2026
June 18, 2026
June 11, 2026
June 4, 2026
May 28, 2026
May 21, 2026
May 14, 2026
May 7, 2026
April 23, 2026
April 16, 2026
April 2, 2026
March 24, 2026
March 5, 2026
February 19, 2026
February 5, 2026
January 15, 2026
January 1, 2026
December 18, 2025
December 4, 2025
November 21, 2025
November 21, 2025
November 6, 2025
October 23, 2025
October 16, 2025
January 6, 2023
January 5, 2023
January 4, 2023
Stay up-to-date with exclusive news and market updates in [Location].
Ally's mission is to offer a white glove experience and exemplary results to every customer while showcasing her love for the Florida Keys community, vast knowledge of the real estate market, and passion for exceeding expectations.
Ally's mission is to offer a white glove experience and exemplary results to every customer while showcasing her love for the Florida Keys community, vast knowledge of the real estate market, and passion for exceeding expectations.