Meet Ally
Florida Keys Luxury Real Estate
Your Middle and Lower Keys Advisor
Ally is a top-producing real estate advisor with Ocean Sotheby's International Realty, serving buyers and sellers throughout the Middle and Lower Florida Keys. Since relocating to the Keys in 2016, she has built a reputation for delivering exceptional results, personalized service, and an elevated client experience, successfully closing more than $150 million in real estate transactions.
A fifth-generation Floridian, Ally combines deep local market knowledge with a genuine passion for the island lifestyle she calls home. Her expertise spans waterfront estates, luxury vacation homes, investment properties, and primary residences, allowing her to guide clients through every stage of the buying and selling process with confidence and clarity.
Recognized among the top 1.5% of real estate professionals in America by RealTrends Verified and voted as Marathon’s “Best Realtor”, Ally has consistently ranked among the Florida Keys' top-producing agents. Her market insight, strategic pricing expertise, skilled negotiation, and commitment to client advocacy have contributed to numerous notable and record-setting sales throughout the region.
What truly distinguishes Ally is her belief that luxury is defined by the experience, not simply the price point. Every client receives the same level of care, communication, and attention to detail, whether purchasing a first home, selling a family property, or acquiring a waterfront estate. Supported by a carefully curated network of trusted local professionals, Ally provides a seamless, concierge-style approach designed to simplify the process and exceed expectations.
Beyond real estate, Ally remains deeply invested in the community she serves. She is a graduate of Leadership Monroe, an active member of the Marathon Chamber of Commerce and Rotary Club of Marathon, and has previously served in leadership roles with the Marathon and Lower Keys Association of Realtors, including President, and Baptist Fisherman's Hospital Foundation Board. Her dedication to both the industry and the community reflects her commitment to helping the Florida Keys thrive.
When she's not working with clients, Ally enjoys boating the islands with family and friends, staying active, exploring local restaurants, and spending time with her husband, a Monroe County Firefighter/Paramedic, and their two goldendoodles, Daisy and Delilah.
Whether buying, selling, or investing, Ally's mission remains the same: to provide expert guidance, exceptional service, and a level of care that transforms real estate transactions into lasting relationships.
Ally is hands down the best Realtor in the Keys. She assisted us with buying our first home working with a VA loan and Hometown Heroes. She showed us exactly what we wanted to see and didn't try to show us things that we weren'...
Ally was very responsive to our needs from the start. She understood what we were looking for but most importantly the property types we were not interested in and streamlined our searches to pinpoint viable options. Since we l...
Honestly, I was impressed throughout my home purchase. The support I received with a difficult mortgage was fabulous. Ally had the knowledge and professionalism needed to assist me in making decisions and helped me get through ...
Our experience working with Ally was truly pleasurable. She discussed the pricing of our home and took our feelings into account during the listing process. After we listed it she kept us informed and up to date on the location...
Ally has been helpful, thorough, and professional. It was a pleasure to work with her in selling our home. She is easy to communicate with and is prompt in finding answering and following through on all requirements and paperwo...
We decided to move to The Keys from the North East. Ally was there to help us every step of the way. It took us 6 months to decide and ally was more than happy to help the entire time. She has tons of local knowledge and local ...
We worked with Ally on the purchase of our first home. She was extremely persistent in finding us the perfect home, guided us through the entire process, and answered any of our questions (and there were a lot) promptly, day, n...
I came to Ally with no familiarity with the lower keys area, knowing that I was focused on investment there. Ally's quick response, keen intellect in the area, and competitive intel helped me succeed. She immediately recognized...
I've purchased a few multimillion-dollar homes in The Keys and Ally is the only REALTOR I will use. She does exactly what I ask and is polished and motivated. She followed up with me on all my calls or emails.
Ally was wonderful in helping assist us to sell our home! She paid attention to every detail and made sure the process went smoothly! Highly recommend Ally if you are looking for a truly professional REALTOR.
We highly recommend Ally Kelley. She knows the market and got us multiple offers the first weekend. Great communication from the moment we first talked to her about listing our property to closing.
